• Register
  • Login
  • Persian

Islamic Philosophical Doctrines

Scientific Journal
  1. Home
  2. A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism

Current Issue

By Issue

By Author

By Subject

Author Index

Keyword Index

About Journal

Aims and Scope

Editorial Board

Peer Review Process

Publication Ethics

Indexing and Abstracting

FAQ

Journal Metrics

News

Related Links

Article processing and publishing costs

A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism

    Author

    • Hamed Sajedi

    Corresponding Author, Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy of Humanities, Research Institute of Hawzah and University (RIHU), Qom, Iran

,

Document Type : Research

10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570
  • Article Information
  • References
  • Download
  • How to cite
  • Statistics
  • Share

Abstract

The nature of the 'self' is a significant topic in the philosophy of mind and can play a pivotal role in any philosopher's intellectual framework. Historically, the Personal Identity Argument has been advanced as an argument in favor of Substance Dualism. In contrast, Physicalism attempts to avoid accepting an immaterial reality by proposing a material criterion for personal identity. However, in contemporary philosophy of mind, the introduction of certain thought experiments has given rise to a new form of this argument, which presents a fresh challenge to Physicalism. This article investigates this new line of reasoning. We will demonstrate that while Shoemaker's (Body Swap) thought experiment cannot substantiate Substance Dualism, Williams' Brain Division experiment and Swinburne's (Half-Brain Transplant in Identical Twins) experiment can be used to argue for it. Conversely, Physicalist solutions such as "revising the identity criterion" and "multiple possession" lead to unacceptable consequences.

Keywords

  • Personal Identity
  • Body Swap
  • Brain Division
  • Multiple Possession
  • Substance Dualism

Main Subjects

  • Islamic Philosophy
  • XML
  • PDF 1.06 M
  • RIS
  • EndNote
  • Mendeley
  • BibTeX
  • APA
  • MLA
  • HARVARD
  • CHICAGO
  • VANCOUVER
References
  1. ابن‌سینا، حسین بن عبدالله. (2007). رسالة أحوال النفس. پاریس: دار بیبلیون.
  2. اولسون، اریک ت. (1394). «این‌همانی شخصی» در: دانشنامۀ فلسفۀ استنفورد، (ترجمۀ یاسر پوراسماعیل). تهران: ققنوس.
  3. رازی، فخرالدین محمد بن عمر (فخر رازی). (1407). المطالب العالیة من العلم الالهی. بیروت: دار الکتاب العربی.
  4. سوئینبرن، ریچارد. (1402). ما نفسیم یا بدن؟ (ترجمه و تعلیقات مهدی ذاکری). قم: پژوهشگاه حوزه و دانشگاه.
  5. ساجدی، حامد. (1402). «نقد مواجهۀ فیزیکالیسم با مسئلۀ تغییر بدن در برهان این‌همانی شخصی». آموزه‌های فلسفۀ اسلامی، 18 (33)، 149-178. https://doi.org/10.30513/ipd.2024.6238.1546
  6. سادات‌منصوری، محمد. (1396). گامی به‌سوی تجرد نفس؛ بررسی یک استدلال در دو سنت فلسفی. تهران: فلوطین.
  7. سبزواری، هادی. (1369). شرح المنظومة. تهران: نشر ناب.
  8. سهروردی، شهاب‌الدین. (1375). مجموعه مصنفات شیخ اشراق. تهران: مؤسسۀ مطالعات و تحقیقات فرهنگی.
  9. شیخ‌رضایی، حسین. (1389). «هویت شخصی؛ نگاهی به چند رویکرد رایج». نقد و نظر، 15(2)، 134-152.
  10. شیخ‌رضایی، حسین؛ کرباسی‌زاده، امیراحسان. (1402). آشنایی با فلسفۀ ذهن. تهران: هرمس.
  11. طوسی، نصیرالدین محمد بن محمد. (1407ق). تجرید الاعتقاد. قم: دفتر تبلیغات اسلامى‌.
  12. شیرازی، محمد بن ابراهیم (ملاصدرا). (1981). الحکمة المتعالیة فی الأسفار الأربعة. بیروت: دار إحیاء التراث العربی.
  13. همازاده ابیانه، مهدی. (1398). «تأملی فیزیکالیستی بر برخی از مهم‌ترین ادلۀ تجرد نفس نزد ابن‌سینا و ملاصدرا». حکمت سینوی، 23(61)، 123-141. https://doi.org/10.30497/ap.2019.75322
  14. Butler, Joseph. (1906). The Analogy of Religion, Natural and Revealed. London & New York: J. M. Dent & E. P. Dutton.
  15. Chisholm, Roderick. (1979). Person and Object: A Metaphysical Study. La Salle: Open Court Publishing Company.
  16. Garrett, Brian. (2006). What Is This Thing Called Metaphysics?. London & New York: Taylor & Francis Group.
  17. Leibnitz, Gottfried Wilhelm. (1916). New Essays Concerning Human Understanding, (2nd ed). Chicaco & Landan: The open court publishing Company.
  18. Lewis, David. (1969). ‘Survival and Identity’, reprinted in The Identities of Persons, A. O. Rorty(ed), Los Angeles: University of California Press, p. 17-41.
  19. Noonan, Harold. (2019). Personal Identity. London: Routledge.
  20. Nozick, Robert. (1981). Philosophical Explanations, Cambridge: The belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
  21. Parfit, Derek. (1995). ‘The Unimportance of identity’, In H. Harris (ed.), Identity. Oxford University Press. p. 13-45.
  22. Reid, Thomas. (1852). Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man, Cambridge: John Bartlett.
  23. Shoemaker, Sydney. (1963). Self-knowledge and Self-identity, Ithaca: N.Y. Cornell University Press.
  24. Wiggins, David. (1980). Sameness and Substance, Oxford: Blackwell.
  25. Williams, Bernard. (1973). Problems of the Self: Philosophical Papers, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  26. Williams, Bernard. (1970). ‘The Self and the Future’, The Philosophical Review, 79 (2), 161-180. https://doi.org/10.2307/2183946
    • Article View: 308
    • PDF Download: 268
Islamic Philosophical Doctrines
Volume 19, Issue 34 - Serial Number 34
June 2024
Pages 79-108
Files
  • XML
  • PDF 1.06 M
History
  • Receive Date: 18 December 2024
  • Revise Date: 05 February 2025
  • Accept Date: 09 June 2025
  • Publish Date: 21 June 2024
Share
How to cite
  • RIS
  • EndNote
  • Mendeley
  • BibTeX
  • APA
  • MLA
  • HARVARD
  • CHICAGO
  • VANCOUVER
Statistics
  • Article View: 308
  • PDF Download: 268

APA

Sajedi, H. (2024). A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism. Islamic Philosophical Doctrines, 19(34), 79-108. doi: 10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570

MLA

Sajedi, H. . "A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism", Islamic Philosophical Doctrines, 19, 34, 2024, 79-108. doi: 10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570

HARVARD

Sajedi, H. (2024). 'A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism', Islamic Philosophical Doctrines, 19(34), pp. 79-108. doi: 10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570

CHICAGO

H. Sajedi, "A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism," Islamic Philosophical Doctrines, 19 34 (2024): 79-108, doi: 10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570

VANCOUVER

Sajedi, H. A New Formulation of the Personal Identity Argument in Favor of Substance Dualism. Islamic Philosophical Doctrines, 2024; 19(34): 79-108. doi: 10.30513/ipd.2025.6592.1570

  • Home
  • About Journal
  • Editorial Board
  • Submit Manuscript
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemap

News

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons — Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).

Newsletter Subscription

Subscribe to the journal newsletter and receive the latest news and updates

© Journal management system. designed by sinaweb